Captain′s Row Historic on Sag Harbor′s Main Street - Waterview
Captain′s Row Legacy, Reimagined Water Views Over Otter Pond Set within Sag Harbor′s coveted Main Street Historic District, directly overlooking Otter Pond, this impeccably restored 1850s Captain′s Row residence pairs authentic period architecture with a refined, modern sensibility. The result is a rare offering-water views, village walkability, and a turnkey interior that feels both elevated and deeply livable. The main level unfolds with a series of light-filled living spaces designed for both quiet retreat and effortless entertaining. Multiple sitting rooms, a library/den with flexibility for guest overflow, and a gracious dining area are unified by custom lighting, curated finishes, and a clean, contemporary aesthetic. The chef′s eat-in kitchen is thoughtfully appointed with high end appliances including a Bertazzoni five-burner range, Miele dishwasher etc. A full bath and separate laundry room complete the floor. Upstairs, the primary suite captures postcard-worthy views across Otter Pond. Two additional guest bedrooms overlook the landscaped grounds and are bathed in warm afternoon light. A serene full bath with soaking tub and shower serves the level. The fully renovated lower level adds meaningful versatility, with conditioned space ideal for a media room, fitness studio, or creative workspace. Outdoors, mature landscaping frames a private garden designed for relaxed entertaining, featuring a sculptural concrete dining table, lounge seating, and sun areas. The classic front porch offers a timeless vantage point for morning coffee or sunset reflections over the water. A rare and valuable upside: approvals from the Board of Health and Architectural Review Board allow for an 18′ x 10′ pool, along with a building permit for a new septic system enabling a fourth bedroom-enhancing both lifestyle and long-term value.
